456   Clause 1 to 13 revision

View All Issues for Part 7-2 (2003)

If you want to see other tissues for this part.

This tissue has following status: green

Proposer: Karlheinz Schwarz , SCC

Page:

Clause: 01

Paragraph:

Category: Issue for edition 2 of this part

Issue: This tissue is intended to serve as a single entry point for the revision of clauses 1 to 13. Tissues with regard to clauses 1 to 13 will get a reference to this "single entry point" tissue.

The revised text for clauses 1 to 13 will be made available in this tissue.

Proposal:

Discussion Created Status
?
 Ballot until Editor
That versions have been taken as input to the CD of Edition 2 11 Jul 07 green Editors Group
First complete draft Ed2 for 7-2 posted:

<<61850-7-2_Ed2_Complete_R0-01_2007-04-14.pdf>>

For discussion in Seoul.		 16 Apr 07 final proposal SCC
Karlheinz Schwarz
Please find attached the revision of clauses 1 to 13; clauses 11-13 have been added in this version:

<<61850-7-2_Clause1-13_R0-06_2007-03-17.pdf>>

Please comment by April 13, 2007.
18 Mar 07 final proposal 2007-04-13 SCC
Karlheinz Schwarz
Please find attached the revision of clauses 1 to 10 (clauses 9 and 10 hae been added, clauses 1 to 8 have been updated according to the comments I received:

<<61850-7-2_Clause1-13_R0-05_2007-02-14.pdf>>

Please comment by March 14, 2007.		 15 Feb 07 final proposal 2007-03-14 SCC
Karlheinz Schwarz
Please comment by 05.02.2007 06 Jan 07 final proposal 05.02.2007 SCC
Karlheinz Schwarz
Attached second document ... 06 Jan 07 final proposal SCC
Karlheinz Schwarz
Please find the draft text for clauses 1 to 8 (including Logical Device) of Ed2 attached:

<<61850-7-2_Clause1-13_R0-04_2007-01-06_with-ChangeBars.pdf>>
<<61850-7-2_Clause1-13_R0-04_2007-01-06_withOUT-ChangeBars.pdf>>

This text is intended for immediate review by WG10 and tissue group members. The crucial issues of the draft left for further discussions and the comments received will be discussed in San Diego on February (7.-9.).

Enjoy.		 06 Jan 07 final proposal SCC
Karlheinz Schwarz
Comment on "LOGICAL-DEVICE is now replaced in the figure by unknown Logical Device"

We have decided (for the time being!) that we use more or less "informal" names unless we really write a formal definition. These diagrams a not formal ... they are descriptive.

"," is optional ... use "," consitently ...
---------------------
Comment on "GSSE"
removed link between GSSE and Data Set
---------------------
Comment on "Log in Server ..."

We decided that Logs should (for the time being) be allowed in Server, LD, and LN ... not only in LLN0
06 Jan 07 final proposal SCC
Karlheinz Schwarz
According to the new figure 3, I have these comments :
- GSSE may not refer to a Data Set (refer to table 30)
- in my mind, Server, Logical Device and Logical Node do not contain any Log because only Logical Node Zero does !		 04 Jan 07 final proposal EDF R&D
jean-philippe tavella

approved by
SCC
Karlheinz Schwarz
The new figure 2 is better than the one in the previous version.

Nevertheless, may I do the following remarks :
- why class names have been changed (e.g. correct LOGICAL-DEVICE is now replaced in the figure by unknown Logical Device) ?
- in the text, the comma between LOGICAL-NODE and "and DATA" should be suppressed, should not it ?		 04 Jan 07 final proposal EDF R&D
jean-philippe tavella

approved by
SCC
Karlheinz Schwarz
The conceptual information models shown in Figure 2 – "Basic conceptual class model of the ACSI" and Figure 3 – "Conceptual service model of the ACSI" have been completely revised.

The editors have decided to simplify the diagrams. The intention of these figures is to provide a first and general overview. Therefore we have used a generic "modeling language" which is intended to show the basic relations between the various definitions in IEC 61850-7-2.

Seveal relations have been revised for correctness.

Please check the attached document for details:

<<Excerpt_61850-7-2_Clause1-13_R0-03_2006-12-23.pdf>>		 23 Dec 06 final proposal 2007-01-31 SCC
Karlheinz Schwarz