208 NumCntRs - Control?

View All Issues for Part 7-4 (2003)

If you want to see other tissues for this part.

This tissue has following status: green

Proposer: Christoph Brunner , UTInnovation

Page: 46

Clause: 5.7.3, 5.8.1

Paragraph:

Category: Issue for edition 2 of this part

Issue: Within the LNs GSAL and IARC, the data NumCntRs is defined as controllable integer (INC). The explanation given is not clear - nor is the reason why it is a controllable integer.

I assume, it refers to the number of resets of OpCntRs. It is however not clear, why the number of resets of OpCntRs is only counted for these two logical nodes (GSAL and IARC)?

In addition, when this counter (NumCntRs) is again contollable, I assume it is to reset the counter of the number of resets. Does this make sense? If yes, why do I then not need as well a counter of the number of resets of NumCntRs?....

Proposal: Exchange the explanation of NumCntRs with: Number of times the resetable operation counter (OpCntRs) has been reset.

Cange CDC of NumCntRs fom INC to INS and add the data in the group status information.

Consider to delete NumCntRs from LN IARC.

Discussion	Created	Status ?	Ballot until	Editor
Accepted	08 Jun 06	green		ABB Klaus-Peter Brand
Set to final proposal since it was accepted at the last WG10 meeting in Merida and no additional comments appeared	14 May 06	final proposal	31.05.2006	ABB Klaus-Peter Brand
accepted	29 Mar 06	red		ABB Klaus-Peter Brand
I have the feeling that OpCntRs andNumCntRs are only within IARC because of (wrong?) copying from GSAL. SO, either remove both, or give them a reasonable meaning.	20 Sep 05	white		ABB Wolfgang Wimmer